The one where... by Geraint Clarke

In stock
Downloadable Video
96% of 100

A magician fooler I’ve kept locked away…


I’m not paid to create magic here. I publish only when I feel I can add real value to the community - Geraint Clarke

I’m lucky enough to travel the world with Ellusionist and see more magic than most.


Every magician that meets me wants the top shelf liquor, they want to be fooled.


They don’t want to see something they’ve seen before. They expect me to have something new in my back pocket that will blow them away. An exclusive.


This is one that I’ve been using to **** magicians up at conventions & lectures all over the world… for years.




Imagine I asked you to buy a strawberry ice-cream from me… moments after telling you it was the worst flavour. That’s what’s going to happen TODAY. But instead of ice-cream, it’s a card trick.


I’m not going to try and ’sell’ you something. Instead I’m going to tell you something and my hope is, at the end, you’ll still want to buy it.


Good magic is when your spectator's expectations and the reality of what just happened are misaligned. If they expect it to happen and it happens, you’ll get a golf clap.


However, if they expect a good trick and you show them a great trick, the magic hits harder.


I’m not paid to create magic here. I publish only when I feel I can add real value to the community - Geraint Clarke



Using that rule, the worst plots in magic are ACAAN and Oil & Water. In ACAAN, they name a card and number and you ask them to count down. By the time they get a few cards down, they already expect their card to be at the position that they named. So their expectations and the reality of the effect align. It’s not a good trick.




Hear me out. Now imagine that deck was blank and the ONLY card in the entire deck is the card they named and it’s at the position they named. Now that’s a great trick. They expected it to be in the position they named and it is. Okay… But you flip over the cards and their free choice is the only card that exists. Their tiny mind is BLOWN. The reality exceeds their expectations.




The cards mix. They separate. They mix again. They separate again. They mix again. They separate again.


Now to finish, the deck separates too. 


After the first phase, your audience now expects it to happen. So every subsequent phase is on a level plane. Their expectations and reality are aligned.




My approach to creating my version was simple.


1: It needs to be impromptu. 2: No extra cards. 3: I should be able to borrow a deck if the moment calls for it. 4: It needs to have 2 potential methods for each phase, so I can repeat it with the same audience watching and still not get caught. 5: At least one of those two methods needs to be VERY easy to do, so I can teach my younger fan base, or attendees in my lectures can do it right away. 6: It must get more impressive each phase. 7: The final phase has to kick them in the teeth outta nowhere (not literally). 8: The story or presentation should make sense. 9: The magic absolutely must happen in the spectator’s hands.


Thus, “The one where they mix and unmix, the same happens again but then they vanish” by Geraint Clarke was born.


In the first phase they’re mixed fairly, face-down and unmix themselves.


In the second phase the magic happens face-up in the spectators hands, with everything looking so fair. (This is achieved with a crazy sleight you’ve never seen before).


The third phase, the ‘water’ cards vanish from the intense heat of a flame from a lighter (or a pretend one - we’re magicians after all).


It escalates in impressiveness towards a finale they could never expect.


Taste is subjective, but for me, it’s made the oil & water plot fun again.


Those who know me by now know that I NEVER EVER EVER release magic to the industry, or put my name behind something unless I’ve fully worked and developed it over years.


I don’t produce Instagram magic or intensely gimmicked visuals. I produce magic that can be done any time, anywhere and pack the same punch whether the audience does magic or not.


So you can trust me when I tell you that I’ve seen enough bad tricks in my life to know what makes a good one… and my reputation of best-sellers at Ellusionist means more to me than a quick buck.


I’m not paid to create magic here. I publish only when I feel I can add real value to the community (or when you incredible magicians I meet boost my self-esteem on an original effect).


This trick isn’t the best one you could ever do, but it’s the best strawberry ice-cream that I can offer you. The best rendition of the worst flavour.


FREE with a membership - or download the secret at Ellusionist for $9.


- Geraint Clarke @ellusionist


Customer Reviews

Items 1 to 10 of 11 total

Show per page
  1. Sam

    This is probably one of my favourite downloads on ellusionist and it being so cheap makes this a must-buy for every magician :)
  2. Dean

    For under 10 pounds this is one of the best purchases totally enjoyed the teaching with the oriental music in the background felt like i was being taught by Mr Myagi ,mix this with ben earls oil and water to finish and you have created a beautiful effect .p.s make sure the oriental music is in the background as you chat about oil n water science to your victims.
  3. Weston

    It's impromptu, it's straightforward, and you end clean. What's not there to love?? Add on to Geraint's great and relaxed teaching, this one is a win.
  4. Lorenzo

    Awesome!!! It's worth every cent. The idea is very clever and creative. It does require some practice, but nothing really complicated, I think in 2 or 3 days practicing it everyone can get it to work, and the video is explained in different perspectives and in slow motion. Well done Geraint
  5. Pavel

    Alright, damn. I never liked Oil and Water concept and then I see this guy that also hates it, but at the same time he puts up a video of teaching a version of it. And a GREAT ONE. I had fun practicing this, it is a little sneaky, but nothing that hurts your knuckles. And I will use this. I will use Oil and Water, damn, never expected to say this. Thank you!
  6. Summary

    Great trick and worth the money I really like it.

    **Ellusionist addition - we suspect this may be a fake name**
  7. Summary

    Great trick but not for beginners, It requires lots of practice with moves even experienced magicians have not seen. Put the time in and you will have a winner.
  8. hari

    It's really very good
    Nice 3 phase oil and water
    The 3rd phase require a Little bit of practice and it's the best part among the whole routine
    Love it , thanks geraint for sharing it
  9. Kris

    Very very well made video. This routune has 3 phases. I already perform phase 1, but guys.. phase 2 and 3 are so brilliant. Easy but completely mind blowing. Trust me, today GC will put your oil and water routune to the next level!! Thank you Bro!!
  10. Thomas

    Great routine ! My favourite version of oil and water, really easy to perform, and the explanation are very clear. Thanks !